Debt-to-Equity Swap in Times of Crisis
11/17/2026
Author
Markus Fellner
Partner
Florian Henöckl
Counsel
The financing structures of modern corporate groups are highly complex and diverse, even where companies have solid credit ratings. In times of crisis, when financial stability comes under pressure, the priority is to safeguard the company's liquidity and align its financial liabilities with its actual debt-servicing capacity.
Successful restructuring generally requires a comprehensive strategy. In addition to operational, strategic and earnings-related measures, financial restructuring steps must also be taken, such as strengthening liquidity and adjusting the debt side of the balance sheet. In some cases, considerations regarding the required equity ratios in dealings with third parties (such as customers and public authorities awarding contracts) may also come into play.
One key instrument of financial restructuring, which has proven effective in practice, is the conversion of debt into equity – the so-called Debt-to-Equity Swap.
1. Comprehensive Analysis and Strategic Direction
Every financial restructuring measure must begin with a thorough analysis of the company in crisis or the corporate group as a whole. Only in this way is it possible to identify the key parameters that determine the success or failure of the restructuring.
Once it has been established that the company's debt burden needs to be reduced, a Debt-to-Equity Swap offers an effective means of strengthening the balance sheet by reducing liabilities. However, the specific implementation of such a debt-for-equity exchange can vary considerably depending on the individual circumstances and requirements of the case at hand.
2. Traditional Debt-to-Equity Swaps and Their Limitations
In a traditional Debt-to-Equity Swap, the parties agree on a direct exchange: the lenders' claims against the company are exchanged for existing equity interests in the company. In return for the transfer of shares, the lenders waive their claims against the company.
In practice, however, this approach is not always attractive to creditors. The reason lies in the risks involved if the restructuring fails:
Once the claims are waived, they are extinguished. If the company's restructuring subsequently fails, creditors can no longer assert any claims against the debtor.
Furthermore, the transition from debt provider to equity holder entails a fundamental change of role. The new role as a shareholder always requires an appropriate legal framework (including due consideration of regulatory implications) and the definition of rules of conduct (e.g. in the form of a Code of Conduct).
3. Structured Alternatives to Traditional Debt-for-Equity Exchanges
3.1. Assumption of Debt by Shareholders (“Hive-up” Transaction)
Under this structure, a shareholder of the company in crisis (which may also be an indirect shareholder) assumes the company's existing liabilities by way of a debt assumption. This reduces the company's debt at entity level and creates structural subordination.
(i) Repayment Claim
As a result of assuming the debt, the shareholder taking over the liabilities generally acquires a repayment claim against the company in the amount of the debt assumed.
(ii) Economic Equity
For this claim to qualify as economic equity at the level of the operating company, it must be subordinated pursuant to Section 67(3) of the Austrian Insolvency Act (Insolvenzordnung – IO).
(iii) Group Perspective
Although this structure reduces the liabilities of the company in crisis, it leaves the liabilities of the tax-consolidated corporate group entirely unchanged.
3.2. Recovery Certificate (Besserungsschein)
A recovery certificate allows for temporary financial relief without immediately diluting the existing shareholder structure. In return for the creditor waiving its claim, the company issues a recovery certificate to the creditor.
(i) The Condition
The creditor's waiver of its claim is subject to a resolutory condition. It is conditional upon the company achieving individually agreed financial targets or performance indicators in the future.
(ii) Effect
If these targets are achieved, the liability (potentially including interest) becomes repayable again.
(iii) Limitation
This instrument provides only conditional and therefore temporary balance sheet relief. The company does not issue any new shares in this process.
3.3. Virtual Profit Participation Certificates (Virtual Profit Participation)
This model uses an intermediate holding company (HoldCo) to enable creditors to participate in the company's equity value.
(i) Process
The lender sells its claim against the company in crisis to a third-party company (HoldCo).
(ii) Instrument
In return, the third-party company issues an equity-like instrument to the lenders.
(iii) Balance Sheet Effect
The HoldCo subsequently contributes the acquired claim to the company's capital reserves. This enables the creditor to participate in the company's equity value.
3.4. Qualified Subordination
Another option is the qualified subordination of claims. The specific structure must be tailored to the requirements of the individual case (e.g. qualified subordination pursuant to Section 67(3) IO, with a defined term or subject to a resolutory condition linked to the company's financial recovery or insolvency).
4. Framework
A Debt-to-Equity Swap cannot be considered in isolation. Regardless of its specific structure, it must form an integral part of a viable restructuring concept.
This concept must be supported by appropriate economic assessments – in Austria, in particular, by a sound going-concern forecast (Fortbestehensprognose) or comparable forecasts under other jurisdictions. The process must also always be accompanied by a comprehensive tax assessment.
An important strategic consideration in international restructurings is the possibility of implementing a Debt-to-Equity Swap even against the wishes of shareholders as part of pre-insolvency proceedings. In specific cross-border scenarios, a Debt-to-Equity Swap may also be implemented against the wishes of individual stakeholders.
5. Conclusion
Debt-to-Equity Swaps, in their various forms, are a suitable restructuring tool and are frequently used in practice. However, their implementation involves numerous legal, economic and tax-related pitfalls. By appropriately addressing these challenges, tailored solutions that accommodate the interests of the parties involved can be achieved, providing the company with a sustainable outlook for the future.
Author
Markus Fellner
Partner
Florian Henöckl
Counsel